Cornwall on Hudson photo by Michael Nelson
May 04, 2025
Welcome! Click here to Login
News from Cornwall and Cornwall On Hudson, New York
News
Events
Donate
Our Town
Photos of Our Town
Education
Help Wanted
The Outdoors
Classifieds
Support Our Advertisers
About Us
Advertise with Us
Contact Us
Click to visit the
Official Village Site
Click to visit the
Official Town Site
Cornwall Public Library
Latest Newsletter

Letters to the Editor: New Ideas Needed for Schools

May 25, 2011

To the Editor:

I didn’t realize I lived in such an affluent community – one that would summarily increase taxes by over 5 percent at the same time other communities are implementing austerity measures and cutting costs wherever possible. Nothing demonstrates this cavalier attitude toward my checking account like this quote from the Times-Herald Record of 3/3/11:

”Something was missing when the Cornwall School District's proposed 2011-12 budget was unveiled this week: proposed cuts. While some districts have come out early with budgets calling for cutting personnel and closing schools, Cornwall officials are holding off, hoping for better news out of Albany after lawmakers dig into Gov. Andrew Cuomo's budget.”

Holding off for better news! The mindset of Cornwall school administrators that budget increases are an entitlement are as confounding as the electorate’s succumbing to threats to cancel sports and music lessons by same. No one is challenging the administrators to devise new approaches and solutions to improve our children’s education while minimizing the cost. Administrators in Cornwall approach budgets on a cost-plus basis with not enough accountability for aggressive cost controls [especially their own administrative headcount and salaries.

I’m not saying that we need to lay all the problems with our educational system at the feet of administrators. Educators and parents possess the best ideas for the improvement of our educational system from the simplicity of applying home economics methods or applying business skills to public institutions. Look to inspiration from thought leaders outside our community. For example, browse through http://www.edutopia.org/ for ideas we can apply and join me and other concerned parents and taxpayers in attending more school board meetings in the coming year.

Michael Summerfield
Cornwall, NY


Comments:

Taxes were not increased "summarily"; the tax increase was approved by the majority of voters.

I did a little browsing at edutopia.org. I see nothing there about cost cutting. Can you direct me to the data on the website indicating that implementing their vision will lead to lower costs?


posted by Carlotta Shearson on 05/25/11 at 11:30 AM

Summarily: ?adverb in a prompt or direct manner; immediately; straightaway.

Although I suggested edutopia.org as a source for ideas, try typing "budget cuts" in the search field to find 300+ article, blogs and discussions on how communities across the country are responding to budget cuts. As is often the case, the comments to the original post often provide the most insight. Please enlighten us with any resources you are aware of too.


posted by Michael Summerfield on 05/25/11 at 12:38 PM

We seem to be forgetting that in the recent past, our school district administration was lobbying hard for a bond vote for significant sports infrastructure. It seemed like a high pressure sales job to me, and in light of the fact that our High School's football field was incorrectly proportioned, thereby rendering it essentially illegal for league play leads me to ponder our administration's game plan, in general. The word "hubris" comes to mind.


posted by Rick Gioia on 05/25/11 at 9:52 PM

Rick, to say the football field was incorrectly proportioned is only superficially true. The fact is that one goalpost--or maybe it was a pair of goalposts--was the wrong height by a foot or so is more accurate though less newsworthy. The fault was quickly and easily corrected, a job that you and I could probably have done in an afternoon.

This information comes from neighbor and long-time friend Melanie Mulroy-Robinson, so we can assume it's true. It came to me as correction to a mistake-riddled earlier post of mine, in which I'd bought into a substantial amount of misinformation provided by somebody opposed, for the wrong reasons, to the whole football-field drama.


posted by Stephan Wilkinson on 05/26/11 at 3:04 AM

Thanks for this clarification, Stephan. Still, it's curious that there was never (to my knowledge) a definitive public statement from the school board acknowledging this relatively small mistake, and thereby allowing the rumor-mill to fly.

I guess I'm trying to get back to what Mr. Summerfield has described as a culture of entitlement, and to make the point that during a period of economic stress, the board floated a very ambitious and costly bond proposal for athletics in advance of the annual budget process. By preemptively dangling a potentially large tax increase before residents, the 5% budget increase may have lead many residents to feel they dodged a bullet, and were actually getting a bargain. I find it hard not to pair these two things together.


posted by Rick Gioia on 05/26/11 at 8:50 AM

Yes, you're right, and I don't understand why -nobody- responds on this forum, or in the Local, to questions that should be easy for those in a position of authority to answer, particularly a mayor, trustees, school superintendant, etc.

For example, it's generally assumed that Cornwall's football team "wanted to play in a bigger league" assumedly for the glory, and that we were going to have to pay for the facilities to allow them to voluntarily do that.

Truth is, the football team is REQUIRED to now play in a bigger league, due to a variety of factors including school population. Otherwise, you could have a high school of 5,000 kids setting up a football schedule with a dozen small rural schools so they'd end up with an undefeated season.

but nobody has bothered to explain that, so you have a community outraged by "runaway sports expenses."


posted by Stephan Wilkinson on 05/26/11 at 2:12 PM

Not to digress, but during my term as village trustee, I, on several occasions joined in various dialogue threads on this site to discuss issues. Andrew Argenio also recently posted an open letter to explain what he's been working on. I think the "nobody" characterization is a bit absolute, but not far from the truth.


posted by Rick Gioia on 05/26/11 at 4:53 PM

I think, and what I have heard, is that many people still like the football games at the middle school because so many people can still walk to the games, seems no real harm to continue the tradition of having football there.


posted by j h on 05/31/11 at 11:04 AM

Mr. Schneider, I have no qualms with continuing the tradition of football at the original field. It is certainly worth reflecting on the emotional and practical value that the middle school field has for our community, and perhaps to consider, in retrospect, that given these feelings we missed an opportunity to reinvigorate that site as the high school that it once was. Could it be that we lost sight of that in our rush for the new?

Could this story possibly be an allegory for what is now a misguided direction in our school district? We need to be mindful of the evolution we are on with our school district infrastructure, and to look back at the decisions we have made to get us to this point.


posted by Rick Gioia on 06/07/11 at 9:59 PM

Add a Comment:

Please signup or login to add a comment.



© 2025 by Cornwall Media, LLC . All Rights Reserved. | photo credit: Michael Nelson
Advertise with Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy