Cornwall on Hudson photo by Michael Nelson
May 05, 2025
Welcome! Click here to Login
News from Cornwall and Cornwall On Hudson, New York
News
Events
Donate
Our Town
Photos of Our Town
Education
Help Wanted
The Outdoors
Classifieds
Support Our Advertisers
About Us
Advertise with Us
Contact Us
Click to visit the
Official Village Site
Click to visit the
Official Town Site
Cornwall Public Library
Latest Newsletter

Letters to the Editor: School Budget Process Needs Changes

February 01, 2011

To the Editor:

After recently being invited to serve on the School Budget Advisory Committee, I declined to do so because I do not believe that it provides an effective and meaningful way to participate in the budget process in the manner it is currently conducted.

There would need to be some very significant changes before the activities of this budget committee could be considered as probative, analytical and representative. I identify them below.

1. Not more than 10 members should have children in the school district.

2. Not more than 2 should have involvement with public school education in the district or outside the district, nor be retired from such employment.

3. There should be at least five people who have businesses in the school district.

4. No one can be a relative of anyone who is currently or has been a teacher, administrator or member of the school board.

5. At least half the meetings should exclude the administrators and school board members.

6. The other half would provide ample opportunity to have them answer questions that are generated from the more independent review conducted by members
of the committee without subjecting the committee to the force of intimidation implicit in having a coterie of administrators and board of education members seated at the same table as the committee members.

7. A proposed budget to be submitted to the committee should have in it the necessary policies to eliminate labor costs by 10%.

8. There should be a limit on any capital spending for three years in the absence of a public health or other emergency.

9. There should be an immediate disclosure to the public what policy plans and alternates the district will propose to meet the challenges of reduce revenues and the real property tax cap. The daily newspapers are replete with stories from various school districts throughout the area of proposals for dealing with the financial problems. There is nothing yet being offered to the public by the Cornwall district. If the intention is to have those considered at the time the committee is formulated and meets, that is too late. I don’t think you can reasonably expect volunteers to be able to evaluate serious (hopefully) proposals within the limited confines of the proposed budget committee schedule. The assumption so far is that the school district is not going to propose anything of significant change because if they had those in mind, they should be out on the table already for discussion at the earliest possible time.

10. The administrators should not suggest and there should be a pledge by the school board not to threaten the district or engage in extortionist lobbying by stating:
A. Extracurricular activities will be halted.
B. The sports programs will be sidelined.
C. The district will not accept donations.

11. Answers to the questions I previously raised in five letters to which there has been no district response so that information could be provided to the public. Due to the non-response, valuable time to inform the public has been lost and squandered. That failure thereby has deprived the public (and those who might serve on the budget committee) of important, relevant information that could help them perform their work.

If the public committee activities will be conducted within the standards that I have described above, then I would be happy to spend my volunteer time to assist the school district in meeting the challenges of the day.

Gerald N. Jacobowitz
Cornwall-on-Hudson



Comments:

Identifying characteristics stated in items 1-5 would be a great start for an overhaul of how we manage our schools system. Also bundling extra curricular items within a budget is a threat and we are incensed every time we vote. It Is Not Right!
Very interesting Letter!
Mr Jacobowitz how is your thinking of redrawing district lines? As we cant control New windsor and harrimans zoning we certainly are paying for the effects of it.


posted by J Buescher on 02/01/11 at 12:55 PM

I am told, by somebody far more knowledgeable than I am about school-board matters, that we soon will be given the opportunity to vote on a $39 million bond issue for a new football "stadium" for the high school, so that they have the proper facilities with which to move their football program up one level to a more competitive division, among other things.

But it won't actually be much of an opportunity. The school administrators and board know perfectly well that they can easily summon a bloc of about 2,500 guaranteed-pro voters, made up of parents, teachers, other school-system employees, high-school sports boosters, present and past board members and administration people, etc. Plus people like my wife and me, who have for 35 years reflexively voted "yes" for everything that our school system wanted, simply because we were proud of it and because it had done well by our own children.

This bloc is not an ethereal thing but a cadre well-coordinated through phone and e-mail lists and the like, and its power can easily be brought to bear. Nor will it hurt that, I am told, we will essentially have about 20 days between formal announcement of this bond issue as part of the school budget, and the vote.

This will be the first time since I moved to Cornwall, in 1971, that I'll vote "no" on a school budget.


posted by Stephan Wilkinson on 02/07/11 at 10:42 AM

If the school board and local parents really cared about Cornwall they would scrap the idea of the football stadium, and approach NYMA about sharing/utilizing their facilities.

With the current economic crisis, and the financial crisis at NYMA it just makes sense to try and combine issues financially. We could assist NYMA with their financial crisis, while saving money as tax payers. NYMA might not be part of the COH school system, but it is a school, with good fields.

As a resident of the Village I think it is a crime that the parents and school board attempt to use their children to extort more taxes out of the community, while giving no consideration to what is good for the overall community.

Each household needs to worry about all of the property taxes they pay, not just the school tax.


posted by Melissa Vellone on 02/07/11 at 2:43 PM

But unless we get as organized, or at least as coordinated, as the pro-budget people are, there will be no chance of overcoming a 2,500-vote lead. Which means suggestions for other courses that -might- be followed are just pipe dreams.


posted by Stephan Wilkinson on 02/07/11 at 3:08 PM

Ever wonder why a brand new football field at the brand new high school was never used for high school football games? I've never gotten a definitive answer to this, but I've heard that there were some design miscalculations relating to its dimensions that puts it in violation of rules & regulations. Maybe there's someone out there who could clear this up. If this is true, then the logic behind this budget process needs to be strictly analyzed. The high school buildings are perfectly designed for a photovoltaic solar array on two of its roofs, with the south-facing sections at an optimal angle to maximize electrical generation. If we're going to consider spending money no one has, then perhaps it should be toward a capital improvement project which would, over time, not only pay for itself, but become profitable.


posted by Rick Gioia on 02/08/11 at 12:52 PM

Rick, that's exactly what I've heard--that the Dragon Drive football field can be used for practice all they want, but where do the league games get played? At the OLD football field at the former (Main Street) high school, which at least meets division rules re. dimensions, end zones, etc. But it's not a good enough field for the division into the school wants to move--not enough seating, etc.

Our very own "Friday Night Lights."


posted by Stephan Wilkinson on 02/08/11 at 2:40 PM

How about we do something with the school district that will increase the intellectual edge our graduating students have?

More capital improvements on buildings? When do we get to hear about improvements to the AP programs, the science labs or the mathematical abilities of the students??


posted by Melissa Vellone on 02/08/11 at 4:40 PM

The installation of a PV solar array on the school's roofs could easily include an academic component. A science class could, let's say, make a project of monitoring the electrical output from the array, and correlate it with weather patterns. An economy class could chart the electrical production against current electrical rates from Central Hudson and do various financial projections and cost/benefit analysis. The interface with the main service panel can easily be located in such a way as to permit this kind of relevant learning on many levels. All this, and making the school's meter spin backwards, too!


posted by Rick Gioia on 02/09/11 at 3:29 PM

Add a Comment:

Please signup or login to add a comment.



© 2025 by Cornwall Media, LLC . All Rights Reserved. | photo credit: Michael Nelson
Advertise with Us | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy